Money, Spain
American in Spain? The tax treaty lets the US tax you as if it did not exist, and Spain gives no credit for tax charged because of your passport
For most people moving to Spain, a tax treaty settles the matter: once you are resident, it says which country may tax each kind of income and the other one steps back. If you hold a US passport, the treaty does less than that. Article 1 lets the United States keep taxing its citizens "as if the Convention had not come into effect", so you file in both countries every year for as long as you are American. The part fewer people expect is on the Spanish side. Spain gives no credit for US tax charged only because you are a citizen. The Spanish tax agency says so in its own leaflet on US income, and it means nearly all your relief has to be claimed from the IRS, on a US return, under US limits.
None of this normally means paying full tax twice. It does change which tax counts as the final one, which accounts are safe to touch, and what you should not buy after you arrive. The rules sit in the convention signed in Madrid on 22 February 1990, in force since 21 November 1990, and in the protocol signed on 14 January 2013, in force since 27 November 2019. The protocol rewrote the articles on dividends, interest and capital gains and added new rules on pension funds. It left the saving clause alone.
What is the saving clause in the Spain-US tax treaty?
A saving clause is a sentence that lets a country keep taxing certain people despite everything else in the treaty. Here it is paragraph 3 of article 1: each country may tax its own residents, and by reason of citizenship may tax its own citizens, as if the treaty had not come into effect. Spain gets little from that, because it taxes by residence. The US also taxes people for being American, so in practice the clause works in one direction.
Paragraph 4 lists what survives. Article 24 on double taxation is on that list, along with non-discrimination, the mutual agreement procedure and child support. A US citizen living in Spain therefore keeps very few treaty protections against the IRS, and article 24 is the one that matters most. Before you rely on any of it, you have to be tax resident in Spain in the first place. That has its own tests, and Spain has no split-year treatment, so the year you move needs separate attention.
Why will Spain not credit tax the US charges because you are a citizen?
Because the treaty says so. Article 24, paragraph 1(a), gives a Spanish resident a deduction for US tax actually paid on income the treaty allows the US to tax, "other than solely by reason of citizenship". So for each item of income, ask whether the US could tax it if you were a Spaniard living in Spain. If it could, as with US dividends, Spain credits the tax up to the treaty limit. If it could not, as with a private pension or the sale of US shares, Spain gives you nothing for it. Spanish law then caps any credit at the lower of the foreign tax paid and your average Spanish rate on that income, under article 80 of the income tax law.
The relief for everything else comes from the other direction. Article 24, paragraph 2, makes the US credit Spanish income tax, subject to US law. Paragraph 3 solves a problem that would otherwise wreck that credit, because the US limits its foreign tax credit by reference to foreign income, and a dividend from Ohio is not foreign. For a US citizen resident in Spain, income the US taxes by reason of citizenship is treated as arising in Spain to the extent needed to avoid double taxation. There is one floor: the US must still collect at least what it would have charged a non-citizen.
Here is how that plays out on the same 10,000 euros, for someone whose savings income already sits in the 21 per cent Spanish band, which runs from 6,000 to 50,000 euros. The figures are simplified and ignore exchange rates. Take dividends from a US company first, taxed by the US at 15 per cent. Spain charges 2,100 euros and credits the 1,500 paid to the US, because 15 per cent is what the treaty lets the US charge anyone. You pay Spain 600, and the total is 2,100. Now take interest from a US bank instead, taxed by the US at 22 per cent. The treaty gives that interest to Spain alone, so Spain charges 2,100 and credits nothing. The US charges 2,200 and credits the Spanish 2,100, leaving 100. The total is 2,200. Only the first case produces a Spanish credit, and the money goes to different places.
What happens to a 401(k) or traditional IRA once you live in Spain?
Article 20 makes a private pension for past employment taxable only in the country where you live, so Spain holds the treaty right and the US keeps its citizen's claim on top. Spain's tax directorate went through exactly this in binding ruling V0251/2025 of 5 March 2025, on a retiree with a US plan. It said Spain taxes the money when it is received, as work income in the general part of the return, and that if the US also taxes the person as a citizen, it falls to the US to remove the double taxation under article 24. The general scale runs well above the savings scale and depends on your region, so a large single withdrawal can be expensive.
The ruling also deals with the move people make without thinking about it, a rollover. Paragraph 5 of article 20, added by the protocol, says income from a US pension fund is taxed in Spain only when and to the extent it is paid to you, and not when it passes to another pension fund in the US. A direct transfer to an IRA therefore costs nothing in Spain. If the money reaches you first, even for a moment, the directorate says Spain taxes it, even if you then pay it into another plan. And moving the money into a Spanish pension plan is not a tax-free option at all, because the US plan is not regulated under Spanish or EU rules.
If a US plan holds back tax when it pays you, do not expect to use that in Spain, since Spain sees no credit there on a private pension. The withheld money is a payment on account of your US return, and you only recover it there, through the foreign tax credit, while the full Spanish bill still has to be paid in Spain.
Before you take any money out of a US retirement account from Spain, or roll one over, send us the plan type, the amounts and your move date. We will tell you how Spain sees it and which side of the credit you land on, so the order of events does not cost you.
Is a Roth IRA tax-free in Spain?
Do not assume it. The Roth exemption is a rule of the US Internal Revenue Code, and it tells the IRS what not to tax. The protocol's memorandum of understanding does help you in one way: it names Roth IRAs under section 408A in its list of US pension funds, so paragraph 5 of article 20 should keep growth inside the account out of Spanish tax until money comes out. That is a rule about timing. Nothing in the treaty says a withdrawal is exempt in Spain.
Roth money is the worst fit for the credit system. If Spain taxes a qualified withdrawal, the US has charged nothing, so there is no US tax for that Spanish tax to reduce, and the Spanish tax is simply the cost. Commentary online cites a 2022 binding ruling on Roth accounts, but we could not obtain its official text, so we will not repeat what it is said to conclude. If your Roth is a large part of your plan, get a written opinion on your own account before you become resident, while you still have choices about timing.
Does Spain tax US Social Security and government pensions?
Spain can tax Social Security, and this is where an American does get a Spanish credit. Article 20, paragraph 1(b), says benefits the US pays to a resident of Spain or to a US citizen "may be taxed" in the US. Those words do not make the right exclusive, so Spain taxes them as part of a resident's worldwide income. The agency's leaflet says the resident can then take the deduction, provided the US taxed the income on a ground other than citizenship. The protocol to the treaty applies the same rule to pensions from publicly run funds for non-government work, and it gives Railroad Retirement as the example. We found no published ruling on how the credit works for a citizen, whom the US taxes on both grounds, so keep proof of the US tax you actually paid and raise the point with your adviser.
A government pension follows a different rule. Article 21 keeps a pension for service to the US, a state or a local authority in the US, and the agency says it is exempt in Spain, though it can push up the rate on your other income. That changes if you become Spanish. For someone who is both resident in Spain and a Spanish national, the same article moves the pension to Spain alone, and the US keeps its citizen's claim while you remain American, so it is worth checking before you apply for nationality.
Why can a Spanish investment fund cost an American more?
Spanish banks sell funds to new residents, and for most savers they have a real advantage: article 94 of the income tax law lets you switch from one fund to another without paying tax on the gain. For an American that advantage stops at the Spanish border. The IRS treats a foreign corporation as a passive foreign investment company, or PFIC, if 75 per cent or more of its gross income is passive or at least half of its assets produce passive income, and an ordinary investment fund is built to look like that. Spanish funds are generally treated as PFICs, although we know of no IRS statement naming them.
The default PFIC treatment is harsh. Under section 1291, gains on sale count as excess distributions, taxed as ordinary income, with an interest charge on the amounts assigned to earlier years. You escape it with a qualified electing fund election, but that needs an annual information statement from the fund, so ask the manager before buying, because a fund that does not issue one leaves you without that election. Form 8621 is generally filed for each fund, each year. A bank adviser in Madrid who has never had an American client is unlikely to mention any of this.
What do you file in each country, and when?
The calendar is the part that catches people first, because the two countries do not ask for the same things and no filing in one satisfies the other. These are the main ones for an individual on a calendar year.
- , US Form 1040, worldwide income: due April 15, with an automatic extension to June 15 if you live abroad on the due date. Interest runs from April 15 on anything unpaid.
- , FBAR, filed with FinCEN: if your foreign accounts together exceeded $10,000 at any point in the year, due April 15 with an automatic extension to October 15. Your Spanish current account counts.
- , Form 8938, if you live abroad: above $200,000 on the last day of the year or $300,000 at any time for a single filer, double for a joint return.
- , Form 8621: generally one for each PFIC you hold.
- , Spanish income tax return: usually by the end of June for the previous year.
- , Spanish Modelo 720: 1 January to 31 March, when one category of foreign assets (accounts, securities and insurance, or property) exceeds 50,000 euros. The agency's questions and answers we read do not name retirement accounts, so settle yours with your adviser before the first filing.
On a salary, you choose on the US return between two tools. The foreign earned income exclusion removes up to $132,900 of foreign earnings for 2026, but you cannot also claim a credit for Spanish tax on the excluded part, and it does nothing for pensions, dividends or interest. The foreign tax credit uses the Spanish tax itself, and unused credit can generally go back one year and forward ten, within separate income categories. Spain's rates on earnings often exceed US ones, which is why the choice deserves a real calculation.
Two costs fall outside all of this. The IRS says the foreign tax credit cannot reduce the 3.8 per cent net investment income tax, which applies above $200,000 of income for a single filer and $250,000 on a joint return. And article 2 covers Spain's income and corporation taxes only, so the treaty gives no relief from Spanish wealth tax.
Does the Beckham regime solve any of this?
It solves the Spanish half for those who qualify. Article 93 of the income tax law lets people who move to Spain for work pay under non-resident rules for the year of the move and the next five, and we covered how that fits remote workers separately. It does nothing about the saving clause, and all the US filings stay. Social security contributions are a separate matter again, handled by a different agreement.
Expect both tax authorities to see your accounts. Under the agreement Spain and the US signed on 14 May 2013 to implement FATCA, Spanish banks identify accounts held by US persons and the information reaches the IRS, and the treaty's rewritten article 27 covers exchange of information between the two countries. A sensible order of work for an American arriving in Spain is to list every account by type and country before the first 31 December as a resident, avoid buying a Spanish fund until you have checked it, touch no US retirement account without first working out who taxes it, and prepare both returns together, since each one uses numbers from the other.
Frequently asked questions
Do US citizens living in Spain still have to file a US tax return?
Generally yes, if worldwide income reaches the filing threshold. Paragraph 3 of article 1 of the Spain-US treaty lets the US tax its citizens as if the treaty had not come into effect, and the 2013 protocol did not change that. You file a Spanish return as a resident and a US return as a citizen. Living abroad on the due date gives an automatic two-month extension to file, to June 15, though interest runs from April 15 on anything unpaid.
Can I deduct US tax from my Spanish income tax?
Only when the US could tax that income on a ground other than your citizenship. Article 24 gives the Spanish credit for income the treaty lets the US tax other than solely by reason of citizenship, and the Spanish tax agency says citizenship-based US tax gives no right to the deduction. US dividends qualify up to 15 per cent of the gross amount, while tax on a private pension or a sale of US shares does not. That relief has to come from the US foreign tax credit.
Who taxes my 401(k) if I retire to Spain?
Both countries can reach it, but Spain has the treaty right. Article 20 makes a private pension for past employment taxable only in the country of residence, and a 2025 binding ruling from Spain's tax directorate treats a withdrawal as work income in the general part of the return. The US can still tax you as a citizen and must then give a credit for the Spanish tax under article 24.
Can I roll my 401(k) into an IRA while living in Spain?
A direct transfer to another US pension fund is not taxed in Spain, under article 20, paragraph 5, of the treaty. Ruling V0251/2025 adds that if the money reaches you first, even briefly, Spain taxes it. It also says there is no tax-free route from a US plan into a Spanish pension plan, because the US plan is not regulated under Spanish or EU rules.
This article reflects the convention between Spain and the United States signed in Madrid on 22 February 1990 (in force 21 November 1990), its protocol and memorandum of understanding of 14 January 2013 (in force 27 November 2019), Spain's income tax law, binding ruling V0251/2025 of Spain's tax directorate, the Spanish tax agency's guidance on US income, and published IRS and FinCEN guidance as of November 2026. US thresholds change every year. This is general information, and your own figures need a calculation by an adviser who works on both returns.
Keep exploring
One door always opens another.
Pull the next thread. Each one ends somewhere useful, a clearer shortlist, a real number, a plan you can keep, whether or not you ever work with us.
See where you fit on the map
Slide your grades and budget to see where you fit across Europe, with Spain leading your matches.
Open thisTake the two minute assessment
A few honest questions and you walk away with a personal blueprint, free.
Open thisRead the hard truths
The traps agents paid by commission will never warn you about.
Open thisAsk us on WhatsApp
One honest message. No script, no pressure, a real person who has walked it.
Open thisWe do this for you, properly, every time.
Don't navigate this alone. Take the free 2-minute path finder and get a personalised read on exactly where you stand.
This guide reflects Visagrad's own view and information gathered at the time of writing. Rules, fees, deadlines and timelines can change quickly, and some details may already have moved. Nothing here is official, legal or immigration advice. For accurate, up-to-date guidance built around your own situation, speak with us first.
